Pam Webster first started practice in Anguilla in 1986. John Dyrud joined the firm in 1992
and the partners practiced under the name Webster & Dyrud until the firm adopted its present name in July 1999 when it acquired Mitchell's Chambers, a practice established by Ian Donaldson Mitchell QC in 1980. The firm established offices at Victoria House in 1992 and at Mitchell House on Mr. Mitchell becoming a High Court Judge in 1999.

Mr. Mitchell was appointed as a judge of the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court in 1999. He has since retired as a judge and is Chairman of the Integrity Commission established recently in Anguilla.